Two years later, not much support for Bentley's 5,000 jobs claim
Dec 11, 2012 | 2897 views |  0 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
It looks like Birmingham News reporter Kim Chandler has found the answer to a mystery well known to readers of Bama Fact Check. Or at least part of the answer. Back in 2010, when Gov. Robert Bentley was running for office, he touted his Re-employment Act of 2010 as a measure that would create 5,000 jobs. Bama Fact Check looked into the claim, and gave Bentley a Truth Rating of 4 out of 5. True, the bill had just gone into effect, and hard numbers weren't available. But Bentley had data showing that a similar program, at the federal level, had created a similar number of jobs in the state. We checked in on that claim again and again over the months after Bentley took office. The answer was always the same: the data wasn't in, and it was too early to tell exactly how many jobs were generated by the bill. Well, the data is in now -- at least some of it -- and Chandler beat us to it. According to her story in today's News, only 17 partnerships and corporations took advantage of the tax incentive under the law, creating the equivalent of about 58 jobs. What's missing from those numbers is the participation of small mom-and-pop operations. There's no telling how many of those businesses hired new employees under the tax incentives created by Bentley's bill. Alabama Revenue Commissioner Julie Magee said, again, that it's still too early to measure the success of the program. You can read Chandler's full story here.
Is the Alabama Constitution the longest constitution in the world?
Truth Rating: 4 out of 5
by Tim Lockette
tlockette@annistonstar.com
Nov 18, 2012 | 2831 views |  0 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
THE CLAIM: Advocates of constitutional reform have long claimed that the 1901 Alabama Constitution is longer than any other founding government document, anywhere. On its website, Alabama Citizens for Constitutional Reform calls it the “longest known Constitution in the world.” The Alabama State Bar Association has also called it the “longest constitution in the world.” The claim has been widely repeated in the press. SUMMARY: It's less an established fact than a hypothesis — but it's a hypothesis with very strong support. Law professors and law librarians say they don't know of a longer constitution, but that doesn't mean that there's not one out there. ANALYSIS: With more than 850 amendments governing everything from animal burials to mosquito control, the 1901 Alabama Constitution is clearly a monster. The document stood at 376,006 words on Jan. 1, according to the Council of State Governments, which reports annually on statistics affecting the states. That makes the 1901 Constitution by far the longest of the state constitutions. That's more than four times as long as the next runner-up, Texas, with a constitution that runs to 86,936 words. Oklahoma comes in third with 81,666 words. The shortest state constitution is in Vermont, at 8,565 words. But is it really the longest governing document in the entire world? That's a much harder issue to track. The United Nations has 193 member countries, most of which have written constitutions. Add in constitutions for states, territories and semi-autonomous native tribes, and you've got a lot of words to count. There's no one agency that catalogs and tracks the length of constitutions, and the widespread assertion about Alabama's Constitution appears to have stood for all these years simply because no one has found a way to knock it down. “No one's shown us one that's larger,” Nancy Ekberg, a spokeswoman for Alabama Citizens for Constitutional Reform told The Star in October. In conversations with The Star last week, Ekberg reiterated that while no one has found a larger governing document, she couldn't be absolutely sure there wasn't one. It's a question that law librarians at two law schools — the Cumberland School of Law at Samford University and the University of Alabama School of Law — couldn't answer definitively, when asked by The Star. “I can't really tell you whether it's the longest in the world,” said Cumberland law librarian Edward Craig. “But it's far ahead of any of the other states.” University of Alabama law professor Bryan Fair said the claim was probably true, though he knew of no study that proved the assertion. “We have 5 million people, and there are countries with a billion people where the constitution is not that long,” Fair said. There's one democracy with a billion residents: India, where a post-colonial constitution, written in the late 1940s, has ballooned over the last half-century. Accounts in the press cite India's constitution as the world's longest national governing document — though it does appear to be shorter than Alabama's by a longshot. An English-language version of the Indian Constitution, made available as an online PDF by the Indian Ministry of Law and justice, fills 396 pages in a standard law-book format. The Star's most recent hard copy of the Alabama Constitution, laid out in a similar format, fills 777 pages. Comparing a state constitution to foreign documents, Fair said, was an “apples and oranges” comparison for a variety of reasons. Yet the length of Alabama's document, he said, is in fact a problem. “The problem is that the Constitution becomes inaccessible to the public,” he said. “For the public to understand it, well, that's rendered almost impossible.” Fair cited one notable recent example: Alabama's Nov. 6 vote on an amendment to take segregationist wording out of the Constitution. The measure drew opposition because the amendment included language that denied children the right to an education. But Fair said there was substantial disagreement about the effect that language would actually have, much of it based on the Constitution's complexity. Fair said he believed the “world's longest Constitution” idea may have come from journalist and reform advocate Bailey Thomson, who edited “A Century of Controversy,” a book popular among reform advocates. Thomson died in 2003. In the book, and in a television documentary series, Thomson calls the 1901 document “the nation's longest.” In a speech in 2000, Thomson said it was “probably the longest in the Western world.” The Star found no statement in which Thomson said it was the world's longest. To cover all the bases, The Star also contacted the publishers of the Guinness Book of World Records, longtime chroniclers of superlatives of all sorts. A representative for the company said the length of constitutions is something the company has not tracked. Based on the evidence, or lack of it, Alabama seems to have a strong claim to this dubious world record. But that record could fall at any moment, if someone shows up with a heretofore unknown governing document longer than 376,000 words. Statewide & capitol correspondent Tim Lockette: 256-294-4193. On Twitter @TLockette_Star.
Are half the people in House District 3 living below the poverty line?
Truth Rating: 1 out of 5
by Tim Lockette
tlockette@annistonstar.com
Oct 30, 2012 | 2924 views |  0 comments | 12 12 recommendations | email to a friend | print
THE CLAIM: The website for Democratic District 3 House candidate John Andrew Harris claims the congressional district, which covers a swath of Alabama from Montgomery County to Phenix City to Centre, has a "51.3 percent poverty rate." SUMMARY: Poverty is a big problem in Alabama -- but not that big. The district's poorest county is Macon, with a 27.4 percent poverty rate. Statewide, between 17 and 19 percent of Alabamians live below the poverty line, and the rate in District 3 appears to be about the same. ANALYSIS: Harris, a Lee County Commissioner and former school lunchroom worker for Auburn City Schools, is running against long-term incumbent Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Saks, for the District 3 seat in U.S. Congress. Harris has run a populist Democratic campaign, arguing for the continuation of federal programs that help poor people and advocating more help for returning veterans. That may be one reason why his campaign website calls attention to the district's dropout rate, its crime rate and its poverty rate, which, the site claims, is 51.3 percent district-wide. Alabama is clearly among the nation's poorest states, but the figure from Harris would be alarming, if true. It would give the district, which includes Anniston and Auburn, a poverty rate higher than that of Puerto Rico (45 percent) and twice that of Mississippi (22 percent). A glance at Census Bureau numbers shows that's impossible. The poorest county in District 3 is Macon County, which includes Tuskegee and the surrounding area. The poverty rate there is 27.4 percent. The most prosperous county is St. Clair, on the fringe of the Birmingham metro area, with 10 percent of its population below the poverty line. The Star did a rough calculation, using poverty and population numbers from the 11 counties that are completely within District 3, and found that the actual poverty rate across those counties comes out to about 18 percent. The district also includes parts of Montgomery County, where 18.9 percent of the population lives below the poverty line; and most of Cherokee County, where the poverty rate is 17.6 percent. That would give the district a poverty rate not far from the statewide rate. The Star's county-by-county calculation used 2009 county numbers, the latest available. That year, the statewide poverty rate was 17.5 percent. In 2010, the statewide rate bumped up to 19 percent, according to a Census Bureau report. Those numbers put Alabama in the top tier of poorest states, near Kentucky and New Mexico and just below Mississippi and the District of Columbia. More recent county-by-county numbers from groups such as Voices for Alabama's Children and the Alabama Poverty Project differ slightly from the Star's Census-based figures, but only by a couple of percentage points -- and nothing in the ballpark of 51 percent. Harris told The Anniston Star he got the 51.3 percent figure from campaign worker Sybil Kornman, a former community college grant writer. "She's got all the research," he said. "She's got the numbers." Kornman said she pulled the number from a state report on a six-county area at the core of District 3. In those six counties, including Calhoun, 51 percent of public school kids are getting free or reduced-price school lunches, she said. That's perfectly plausible. According to figures from the Alabama Department of Education, 57 percent of Calhoun County kids, 63 percent of Cherokee County kids and 70 percent of kids in Chambers County were on free or reduced lunch in the 2011-2012 school year. Educators often use the free lunch rate as a measure of poverty in their school districts, and they have their reasons. For one thing, kids are more likely than the general population to live in poverty. The Census Bureau sets the child poverty rate in Alabama at 27.7 percent, fourth highest in the nation. Another reason is that the free lunch program is available to kids from families living at 130 percent of the federal poverty rate. According to the federal government, you're officially poor if you're supporting a family of four on about $23,000 per year. Some anti-poverty advocates argue that that number is set too low, and that the free-lunch number is a more accurate measure of who's struggling economically. "One problem with the poverty number is that it doesn't take into account the cost of housing," said Linda Tilly, of Voices for Alabama's Children. "Of course, the free lunch rate is based on the poverty rate, so it carries that problem with it." Still, the free lunch rate isn't the federal poverty rate, which Kornman acknowledged as soon as The Star mentioned the matter to her. "I'm sorry," she said. "I should have done more fact-checking myself." Within an hour of The Star's call to Kornman, the website had been changed to acknowledge the source of the poverty number, though the 51.3 percent figure remained on the site. Capitol & statewide correspondent Tim Lockette: 256-294-4193. On Twitter @TLockette_Star.
Profile Page for: Matthew
Profile Page for: Steve
blog comments powered by Disqus


Do you have a claim that you would like checked into?
Click here to request a fact check.

Goat Hill Confidential


See who's getting and who's giving.
Click here